Story perspectives

Karmelo Anthony Seeks Judge Recusal After Murder Conviction

7/10/2026

Summary

Karmelo Anthony Appeals

On July 7, 2026, Karmelo Anthony’s lawyers filed motions for a trial and to recuse Judge John Roach.
A Collin County jury convicted 19-year-old of murder for the April 2, 2025 stabbing of Austin Metcalf and sentenced him to 35 years.
Judge Roach said the jury ‘got it right’ and defended his rulings.
The defense alleges the trial barred cameras, limited seats to 27, broke an evidence agreement, and jury instructions impeded a self-defense claim.

Summary

Wilson Appeals

Six attorneys, including former prosecutor Russell Wilson and NAACP president Gary Bledsoe, lead the appeal.
The case sparked a nationwide social-media debate over its racial dynamics, prompting demonstrators to rally outside the Collin County courthouse with rival groups.
Judge John Roach issued a letter praising the trial’s fairness, which opponents say breaches impartiality, while the transcript remains sealed and the defense may view it only in chambers.

History

Historical Context

In April 1992, a jury acquitted four LAPD officers in the Rodney King case and Judge Joyce Karlin commuted Soon Ja Du’s sentence for Latasha Harlins, fueling outrage that sparked riots on April 29, 1992. The unrest killed 63 people, caused roughly $1 billion in damage, and led Mayor Tom Bradley to call in the National Guard. Attorneys Russell Wilson and NAACP leader Gary Bledsoe now question Judge John Roach’s impartiality in Collin County.

1 of 3

Karmelo Anthony Appeals

On July 7, 2026, Karmelo Anthony’s lawyers filed motions for a trial and to recuse Judge John Roach.
A Collin County jury convicted 19-year-old of murder for the April 2, 2025 stabbing of Austin Metcalf and sentenced him to 35 years.
Judge Roach said the jury ‘got it right’ and defended his rulings.
The defense alleges the trial barred cameras, limited seats to 27, broke an evidence agreement, and jury instructions impeded a self-defense claim.

1 / 3