1 of 1
Story summary
- NFL analyst Chris Simms ranked Peyton Manning No. 1 and Tom Brady No. 9 among peak quarterbacks.
- Simms placed the top ten as Manning, Mahomes, Rodgers, Elway, Favre, Allen, Jackson, Marino, Brady, Staubach.
- He argued that Brady depended on the Patriots’ system and could not create plays outside the pocket.
- X users criticized the omission of Joe Montana and questioned Allen’s and Jackson’s spots, while defending Simms’s choice of Manning.
