Story perspectives

Elsie Advances on AGT After Split Judges Vote

7/16/2026

Summary

Elsie Advances

Elsie advanced to the next round of America’s Got Talent after judges voted on her July 14, 2026 audition, where she performed her original soul-blues song “Forgiveless.”
The judges were split, with Simon Cowell (judge) praising her star potential, Howie Mandel (judge) voting no because the backing track hid her voice, and Sofia Vergara (actress, judge) voting yes, saying she liked Elsie.
The audience cheered then booed after Vergara’s comment aired.

Summary

Howie Mandel Returns

Season 21 retains four judges—Mel B, Sofía Vergara, Simon Cowell and Howie Mandel.
Howie Mandel returns for his 16th season after judging seasons 5 through 20.
Mel B, who judged Seasons 8-13 and Season 20, makes her seventh appearance.
The inaugural 2006 panel of Brandy Norwood, David Hasselhoff and Piers Morgan preceded Season 8, which first added a fourth judge.
Night 6 of auditions showcased an opera-ventriloquism puppet act.

History

Historical Context

In 1934 Major Bowes launched Major Bowes' Amateur Hour on New York radio, pioneering audience voting by postcards and phone calls. Ted Mack revived it on TV in 1948, reaching a 1,651st episode and spawning formats like Star Search and America’s Got Talent. The 2026 AGT judges—Simon Cowell, Howie Mandel, Sofia Vergara and Mel B—show the lasting mix of celebrity judges and public voting.

1 of 3

Elsie Advances

Elsie advanced to the next round of America’s Got Talent after judges voted on her July 14, 2026 audition, where she performed her original soul-blues song “Forgiveless.”
The judges were split, with Simon Cowell (judge) praising her star potential, Howie Mandel (judge) voting no because the backing track hid her voice, and Sofia Vergara (actress, judge) voting yes, saying she liked Elsie.
The audience cheered then booed after Vergara’s comment aired.

1 / 3