Story perspectives

Ryan Murphy’s “The Shards” Falters Amid Overwrought Drama

8/8/2026

Summary

Ryan Murphy Debuts

Ryan Murphy launched the TV series “The Shards,” which critics say shows his waning command.
The plot follows teenage Bret Easton Ellis at a prep school writing a novel while a serial killer stalks students.
Reviewers criticize the show for overwrought dialogue, red herrings, and throwback music that drown the story.
They note occasional strong performances, but those moments appear despite Murphy’s world-building.

Summary

Cat Smith Recreates

Production designer Cat Smith used the 1980s film “American Gigolo” as guide and recreated Hamburger Hamlet’s Sunset location with booths, tables, bars and a fireplace.
Set decorator Lori Mazuer built a Lou Hodges collection for Bret’s sourcing pieces on Chairish and 1st Dibs.
Debbie’s pink bedroom features a vanity from Facebook Marketplace and a restored Regency headboard.
Homecoming episodes include a parade float styled after Memphis design that emerged in early-1980s Milan.

1 of 2

Ryan Murphy Debuts

Ryan Murphy launched the TV series “The Shards,” which critics say shows his waning command.
The plot follows teenage Bret Easton Ellis at a prep school writing a novel while a serial killer stalks students.
Reviewers criticize the show for overwrought dialogue, red herrings, and throwback music that drown the story.
They note occasional strong performances, but those moments appear despite Murphy’s world-building.

1 / 2