Story perspectives

Quarterback John Mateer Faces Size Criticism as Prospects Rise

8/14/2026

Summary

Story summary

Quarterback John Mateer drew criticism and defense for his linebacker-type size.
Oklahoma State coach Eric Morris, who recruited Mateer and coached him in 2022, praised his baseball-derived flexibility.
Former NFL player Cooper Manning questioned whether Mateer’s bulk is necessary for success.
Former Kansas State quarterback Collin Klein warned excess muscle can hurt mechanics.
Kentucky quarterback Will Levis faced similar criticism after the Titans chose him in the second round.

1 of 1

Story summary

Quarterback John Mateer drew criticism and defense for his linebacker-type size.
Oklahoma State coach Eric Morris, who recruited Mateer and coached him in 2022, praised his baseball-derived flexibility.
Former NFL player Cooper Manning questioned whether Mateer’s bulk is necessary for success.
Former Kansas State quarterback Collin Klein warned excess muscle can hurt mechanics.
Kentucky quarterback Will Levis faced similar criticism after the Titans chose him in the second round.