Back to today’s briefing

Story perspectives

Judge Recuses Roach, New Judge Hears Anthony Retrial Bid

8/20/2026

44 6 Full Breakdown

Summary

Story summary

Visiting Judge Sid Harle recused Judge John Roach Jr. from Anthony’s case on Aug. 19.
The recusal allows a new judge to hear Anthony’s new-trial request on Thursday.
Defense attorneys argue that Judge John Roach Jr.’s interview, in which he said the jury “got it right,” demonstrates bias.
Prosecutor Bill Wirskye says the trial was fair and the verdict unanimous.
Supporters cheered and chanted “Free Karmelo!” outside the Collin County Courthouse.

History

Historical Context

During the 1973 Watergate prosecutions, Judge John Sirica presided over the grand-jury trial and his rigorous oversight became a model for judicial impartiality; Special Prosecutor Archibald Cox, appointed that May, pursued the investigation that culminated in the 1974 United States v. Nixon decision limiting presidential privilege. The 2024 recusal of Collin County Judge John Roach Jr. by Visiting Judge Sid Harle reflects that legacy.

1 of 2

Story summary

Visiting Judge Sid Harle recused Judge John Roach Jr. from Anthony’s case on Aug. 19.
The recusal allows a new judge to hear Anthony’s new-trial request on Thursday.
Defense attorneys argue that Judge John Roach Jr.’s interview, in which he said the jury “got it right,” demonstrates bias.
Prosecutor Bill Wirskye says the trial was fair and the verdict unanimous.
Supporters cheered and chanted “Free Karmelo!” outside the Collin County Courthouse.

1 / 2