Story perspectives

ACLU Slams San Diego’s Flock Camera Data-Retention Policy

8/21/2026

Left

Vader Pushes Surveillance

A person dressed as Darth Vader addressed San Diego’s Safety and Livable Neighborhoods Committee on August 19, urging Flock surveillance cameras.
Reporters said the stunt highlighted systemic abuses, including police stalking, child monitoring, criminalizing homelessness, and personal surveillance claims.
The Institute for Justice documented 100 police misuses of Flock for stalking and wrongful stops.
The Electronic Frontier Foundation found Flock ALPR data used to probe families for residency fraud.

Right

Vader Demands Cameras

A person in a Darth Vader costume addressed Diego’s Neighborhoods Committee on August 19, urging support for Flock surveillance cameras.
He singled out Council member Jennifer Campbell, accusing her of imprisoning residents with surveillance tech and mocking her with “Jedi mind tricks.”
The speaker used the Darth Vader persona to challenge council members and demand camera deployment.
San Diego operates 550 Flock cameras that record license plates, video, and audio.

Center

Vader Demands Cameras

A person dressed as Darth Vader addressed San Diego’s Safety and Livable Neighborhoods Committee on August 19, urging support for the city’s Flock surveillance cameras.
The ACLU criticized Flock’s new seven-day data-retention policy as a thinly-veiled public-relations move.
San Diego operates more than 550 Flock cameras that record license plates, video, and audio.
In April, police secured a year-long Nova contract, expanding access to external intelligence data.

History

Historical Context

After the Supreme Court’s 1967 Katz v. United States ruling—authored by Justice John Marshall Harlan II—established a reasonable expectation of privacy, later cases like United States v. Jones (2012) and Carpenter (2015) applied mosaic-theory analysis to prolonged surveillance. Today San Diego’s Safety and Livable Neighborhoods Committee debates expanding the city’s 550-camera Flock system, a move criticized by the ACLU and EFF.

1 of 4

Vader Pushes Surveillance

A person dressed as Darth Vader addressed San Diego’s Safety and Livable Neighborhoods Committee on August 19, urging Flock surveillance cameras.
Reporters said the stunt highlighted systemic abuses, including police stalking, child monitoring, criminalizing homelessness, and personal surveillance claims.
The Institute for Justice documented 100 police misuses of Flock for stalking and wrongful stops.
The Electronic Frontier Foundation found Flock ALPR data used to probe families for residency fraud.

1 / 4