Democratic Primary Upsets Over AIPAC-Backed Opponents Signal Shifting Party Stance on Israel

Progressive challengers defeated AIPAC-backed opponents in several 2024 Democratic primaries: Abdul El-Sayed beat Rep. Haley Stevens in Michigan (48.5 %–47.5 %), Peggy Flanagan won in Minnesota, Aisah Wahab triumphed in California’s 14th District, Darializa Avila Chevalier upset Rep. Adriano Espaillat in New York, La Shawn Ford took a plurality in Illinois’s 7th District, Daniel Biss won in Illinois’s 9th District, and Luke Bronin defeated Rep. John Larson in Connecticut (53.5 %–34.7 %).

Newsweek

U.S. public opinion on Israel has shifted since the Oct. 7, 2023 Hamas attack. An AP-NORC poll (June 11-17) found 58 % of Democrats now say the United States is “too supportive” of Israel, up from 45 % in January, while 62 % say it is not supportive enough of Palestinians. A Pew survey (May 4-17) showed Democratic favorable views of the Israeli government fell to 16 % from 59 % in 2018.

Newsweek

• United Democracy Project spent nearly $15 million on Michigan’s Senate primary, with about two-thirds going to Stevens; total AIPAC-related spending in the race approached $30 million.

Newsweek

• UDP contributed roughly $5 million to Illinois’s 7th District (supporting Melissa Conyears-Ervin) and $2.5 million to California’s 14th District (Melissa Hernandez).

Newsweek

• AIPAC donated $200,000 to Rep. Craig’s 2024 campaign and $285,000 to Rep. Espaillat over the past year.

Newsweek

• Despite long-standing AIPAC backing, Rep.

Newsweek

Progressive challengers framed AIPAC’s money as antithetical to grassroots democracy. El-Sayed’s campaign highlighted the “millions of dollars” from UDP as “outside influence.” Flanagan’s win was portrayed as a rebuke of “pro-Israel PAC money” in a state with a sizable Arab-American electorate.

Newsweek

Predictive markets disagree on the Michigan Senate outcome: Kalshi gives Republicans a 54 % chance, while Polymarket gives Democrats a 51 % edge. No consensus exists on which model better reflects voter behavior.

Newsweek

• Oct 7 2023 – Hamas attack triggers shift in U.S. opinion.

Newsweek

• May 4-17 – Pew survey documents declining Democratic favorability toward Israel.

Newsweek

• June 11-17 – AP-NORC poll records rising Democratic skepticism.

Newsweek

• Aug – Primary elections produce the listed upsets.

Newsweek

Defeating AIPAC-backed candidates shows Democratic primary voters are willing to prioritize a more critical stance on Israel. With Democrats needing to flip four Senate seats to regain control, victories in swing states like Michigan could be pivotal. The pattern may encourage more progressive challenges to incumbents linked to foreign-policy lobbying groups, reshaping the party’s platform ahead of the 2024 midterms.

Newsweek

• “I’m very proud of this district for not listening to the hatemongering and really knowing and believing the work that I’ve done,” — Aisah Wahab, rapid transit director

Newsweek