Back to today’s briefing

Story perspectives

Documentary spotlights Nicola Payne case as charges fail

8/27/2026

50 6 Full Breakdown

Summary

Nicola Payne Disappearance

The documentary The Never Ending Murder depicts the 1991 disappearance of 18-year-old Nicola Payne.
Nicola’s relatives narrate the film in chronological order, emphasizing long-term grief and investigation delays.
The series also highlights violence against women, while critics call its title nightmarishly surreal.
At the time of her disappearance, Nicola and boyfriend Jason had a newborn son, Owen.

Summary

Slevin Revives Case

Detective Martin Slevin revived the cold case and secured charges against two men in 2015.
Nicola Payne left Jason’s house on a misty December day, walking six minutes across the Black Pad.
Detective Malcolm Ross identified two suspects by a distinctive car, noting many gaps in their statements.
Flawed handling of original material evidence and limited DNA testing later weakened the prosecution’s case.

Summary

Hadley Reviews Case

The documentary claims to present shocking new revelations that could determine whether Nicola will ever be found.
Detective Chief Inspector Tom Hadley says the inquiry remains under continual review with no new leads.
A specialist family liaison officer continues to support the Paynes and relay investigative updates.
West Midlands Police declined LADbible’s request for comment on alleged evidentiary failings.

History

Historical Context

Sir Alec Jeffreys created DNA fingerprinting in 1984 at University of Leicester, and its first police use in Narborough murders led Detective David Baker to convict Colin Pitchfork on 2 January 1988 after testing blood from 5,000 local men. The national DNA database launched in 1995, enabling detectives like Martin Slevin to reopen the 1991 Nicola Payne disappearance with modern DNA techniques.

1 of 4

Nicola Payne Disappearance

The documentary The Never Ending Murder depicts the 1991 disappearance of 18-year-old Nicola Payne.
Nicola’s relatives narrate the film in chronological order, emphasizing long-term grief and investigation delays.
The series also highlights violence against women, while critics call its title nightmarishly surreal.
At the time of her disappearance, Nicola and boyfriend Jason had a newborn son, Owen.

1 / 4