Story perspectives

Judge Sends Jury Home Deadlocked, Sets Retrial Risk

9/4/2026

Summary

Judge Sullivan Sends Jury

Judge William Sullivan sent the deadlocked jury home without a verdict after six days of deliberations.
Foreperson reported one juror refused to follow instructions on reasonable doubt.
Defense attorney Kevin Reddington asked Sullivan to remove the juror.
Judge Sullivan denied the request to remove the juror.
If the jury remains deadlocked, Sullivan may declare a mistrial, leading to a retrial.

Summary

Scholars Analyze Deadlock

Legal scholars say hung juries occur in only about 5-6 % of criminal trials.
Professor Paul Butler notes unanimous verdicts are rare, making the Clancy deadlock unusually notable.
Retired Judge Jack Lu explains a “dynamite charge” can pressure jurors and hasten a verdict.
Dan Dolan says judges weigh trial length, evidence volume, and juror fatigue before a mistrial.
Rose Zoltek-Jick observes judges also read jurors’ demeanor and exhaustion when assessing deadlock.

History

Historical Context

The 1975 murder trial of John Norman ended in a hung jury, prompting Judge Harold Greene to declare a mistrial after 48 jurors failed to reach unanimity. The courtroom recorded a 5 % deadlock rate, matching national statistics that year, and the case spurred the American Bar Association to issue guidelines on juror fatigue. Today’s deadlocked Clancy case mirrors Norman’s stalemate, as Judge William Sullivan confronts similar procedural pressures and potential retrial. The precedent underscores how unresolved verdicts can reshape trial management and appellate review.

1 of 3

Judge Sullivan Sends Jury

Judge William Sullivan sent the deadlocked jury home without a verdict after six days of deliberations.
Foreperson reported one juror refused to follow instructions on reasonable doubt.
Defense attorney Kevin Reddington asked Sullivan to remove the juror.
Judge Sullivan denied the request to remove the juror.
If the jury remains deadlocked, Sullivan may declare a mistrial, leading to a retrial.

1 / 3