Story perspectives

Umpire Apologizes After Hat Request Leads to Ejection

9/7/2026

Summary

Marmol Ejected

Umpire Doug Eddings told pitcher Hancel Rincon to straighten his hat during his debut.
Manager Oliver Marmol confronted Eddings over the hat request and was ejected for a pitch-clock violation.
Rincon allowed three runs, a triple, a homer and a single before Justin Bruihl replaced him.
The Cardinals beat the Rockies 7–6 at Coors Field on Sept. 4.
Eddings apologized to Rincon after MLB officials said he had gone too far.

Summary

Liberatore to Bullpen

Analysts recommend moving Liberatore to the bullpen after his 5-14 record and nine-start winless streak.
Manager Oliver Marmol could use right-hander Gordon Graceffo in long relief as the rotation reshapes.
Colorado rookie Cooper Hjerpe threw four innings in his MLB debut, the only reliever besides Max Scherzer to do so.
The Cardinals sit 71-72, four games behind the Diamondbacks for the final NL wild-card spot.

History

Historical Context

The 1983 Pine Tar incident, when umpire Tim McClelland nullified George Brett’s home run for exceeding the 25-inch pine-tar limit, sparked a league-wide equipment controversy. Commissioner Bowie Kuhn later reinstated the run after a 2-hour hearing, emphasizing that rule enforcement must balance fairness with game flow. Today's Cardinals-Rockies clash mirrors that dispute, as umpire Doug Eddings ordered rookie pitcher Hancel Rincon to straighten his hat, prompting manager Oliver Marmol’s ejection for a pitch-clock violation. The precedent warns teams that strict equipment and timing rulings can alter game outcomes, urging clubs to prioritize compliance to avoid costly ejections and lost wins.

1 of 3

Marmol Ejected

Umpire Doug Eddings told pitcher Hancel Rincon to straighten his hat during his debut.
Manager Oliver Marmol confronted Eddings over the hat request and was ejected for a pitch-clock violation.
Rincon allowed three runs, a triple, a homer and a single before Justin Bruihl replaced him.
The Cardinals beat the Rockies 7–6 at Coors Field on Sept. 4.
Eddings apologized to Rincon after MLB officials said he had gone too far.

1 / 3