Full Breakdown
Concerns Over Legal Professionals Giving Character References
9/8/2026, 4:40:06 AM
Core Issue
The Lady Chief Justice, Dame Siobhan Keegan, has warned that it is “unwise” for members of the legal profession to provide character references for defendants. She highlighted that judges are not required by law to consider such references, yet they frequently appear in sentencing. Keegan noted that the lack of transparency can disadvantage victims, who often cannot challenge the references in court, and suggested the need for a better system.
Background & Context
Earlier this year, David Lavery, chief executive of the Law Society, gave a character reference for his cousin, who was convicted of serious sexual offences. The reference sparked criticism from victims who argued that the process denied them an opportunity to contest the influence of a legal professional’s endorsement. In response, Keegan said the issue merits a broader discussion within the profession.
Official Statements & Responses
In a wide-ranging interview on BBC Radio Ulster’s *Good Morning Ulster*, Dame Keegan reiterated that while the law does not obligate judges to weigh character references, their use raises concerns about fairness and transparency. She indicated that the sentencing group she leads will review the practice. The Law Society is set to hold a confidence vote among its members regarding Lavery’s conduct, reflecting internal scrutiny of the matter.
Potential Impact
If the sentencing group recommends changes, the legal profession could see new guidelines limiting or regulating the submission of character references by lawyers and other legal officials. Such reforms would aim to enhance victim confidence in the judicial process and ensure that references do not unduly influence sentencing outcomes.
Next Steps
Law Society members are expected to vote on their confidence in David Lavery in the coming days. The outcome of that vote, together with the sentencing group’s review, will shape any forthcoming policy adjustments concerning character references in criminal cases.
