Story perspectives

Kavanaugh Denies Missouri Bid to Reinstate 2025 Map

9/9/2026

Left

Kavanaugh Denies Map

On September 8 2026, Justice Brett Kavanaugh denied Missouri’s emergency request to reinstate its 2025 Republican-drawn congressional map for the November midterm election.
The ruling was hailed by People Not Politicians as protecting the constitutional right to approve district lines in a referendum.
Missouri Supreme Court blocked the map after a petition with 300,000 signatures required a referendum.
State officials waited until the August 4 primary deadline to argue the voter-approval rule excluded redistricting.

Right

Kavanaugh Denies Map

U.S. Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh denied Missouri’s emergency request to reinstate its 2025 Republican-drawn congressional map on September 8 2026.
Kavanaugh issued a one-sentence order alone, without referring the case to the full Court or providing any explanation.
Missouri Supreme Court ordered a November referendum, blocking the map for the general election.
The August primary used the 2025 map after more than 1.2 million voters selected candidates.

Center

Kavanaugh Blocks Map

U.S. Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh denied Missouri’s request to reinstate its 2025 Republican-drawn congressional map on September 8 2026.
The denial upheld the Missouri Supreme Court’s procedural ruling that the map remains suspended pending a voter referendum, emphasizing a state-constitutional authority dispute.
The map would have given Republicans a 7-1 advantage in Missouri’s eight House seats.
People Not Politicians secured a November ballot referendum so voters can decide the map’s future.

Blindspot

Justice Brett Kavanaugh issued a one-sentence order denying Missouri’s emergency request, providing no explanation and not referring the case to the full Court.
Within this story's sources, this detail appears mainly in Right-leaning coverage and receives less attention in Left-leaning and Center-leaning coverage.

History

Historical Context

In 1995 the Supreme Court issued a 5-4 decision in Miller v. Johnson, holding that any redistricting plan that makes race the predominant factor must pass strict scrutiny. The ruling has been cited in the 2026 Missouri case challenging congressional maps, where Justice Kavanaugh issued a denial and Missouri Supreme Court, backed by People Not Politicians, is pushing a voter referendum on the issue.

1 of 5

Kavanaugh Denies Map

On September 8 2026, Justice Brett Kavanaugh denied Missouri’s emergency request to reinstate its 2025 Republican-drawn congressional map for the November midterm election.
The ruling was hailed by People Not Politicians as protecting the constitutional right to approve district lines in a referendum.
Missouri Supreme Court blocked the map after a petition with 300,000 signatures required a referendum.
State officials waited until the August 4 primary deadline to argue the voter-approval rule excluded redistricting.

1 / 5