Full Breakdown
Haaland’s Derby Winner Stirs VAR Controversy at Old Trafford
By Drooid · · How we work
Core Event – VAR-Approved Goal Decides Manchester Derby
On September 13, Manchester City edged Manchester United 1-0 at Old Trafford. Erling Haaland’s strike in the 60th minute was first ruled off-side, then awarded after a lengthy VAR review. The review concluded that Enzo Fernández, although positioned off-side, did not interfere with play, so the goal stood.
Background & Context
Phil Foden was dismissed in the 23rd minute for a kick on Bruno Fernandes, leaving City with ten men for more than 70 minutes. This was the 199th Manchester derby; City’s win marked only the second occasion a visiting side has won after a red card at Old Trafford (Everton in November 2025 and City today). In the summer transfer window City added Iliman Ndiaye for £65 million, while United’s squad changes were modest.
Data & Statistics
- Final score: City 1 – 0 United.
- Goal time: 60th minute (hour mark).
- City played over half the match with ten men.
- Expected Goals (xG): United 0.96, City 0.99.
- Haaland recorded his ninth Manchester-derby goal, one short of the club record.
Official Statements & Responses
Professional Game Referees (Pro Ref) later issued a statement calling the decision “an error of judgment” and announced a review of the incident. United head coach Michael Carrick relayed the officials’ explanation that Fernández “did not interfere,” which he described as “unacceptable.” Defender Lisandro Martínez called the goal an “injustice,” noting that Fernández’s presence in front of him freed Haaland.
Criticism & Opposition
Former United captain Gary Neville expressed confusion over the off-side decision and criticized the ruling.
Conflicting Reports & Gaps
No public clarification has been provided on how the “interference” rule will be applied in future similar situations.
Verbatim Quotes
- “If that's the interpretation of not interfering in the game now, that's really worrying for me. It's a staggering explanation.” — Michael Carrick, manchester united manager
- “It’s worrying, if that’s really how it is, if that’s how the game is seen by those who are officiating it,” — Michael Carrick, manchester united manager
- “We will get there, I’m convinced of that,” — Michael Carrick, manchester united manager
- “This wolf in goal giving you so much confidence,” — Erling Haaland
- “We had a plan and after the red card it completely changed,” — Enzo Maresca, city manager
What’s Next
United’s fourth-quarter financial results are scheduled for publication on September 23, which may shed light on the club’s ability to strengthen the squad ahead of the next derby.