Full Breakdown
Memorial Service for Convicted Killer Stirs Outcry Among Prison Staff and Victims’ Families
By Drooid · · How we work
Memorial Service and Staff Controversy
More than 20 people gathered for a memorial service that included Donna Marie Brand’s family members and several prisoners. Prison officers were reportedly compelled to attend, prompting anger from staff who felt the ceremony honored a woman convicted of a “terrible crime.” Caroline Glachan’s mother declined to comment on any memorial for her daughter’s killer. Margaret McKeich, 68, the mother of the victim, said she was troubled that Brand had not served the full sentence imposed, adding that she harbored no feelings toward the offender.
Crime and Conviction Background
Donna Marie Brand, 47, was found guilty in December 2023 alongside Robert O’Brien and Andrew Kelly for the 1996 murder of 15-year-old Caroline Glachan. Jurors heard the trio arranged to meet Caroline near a bridge by the River Leven on August 25, 1996, where she was repeatedly punched, kicked and struck with bricks or similar objects before being pushed into undergrowth and later discovered in the river. The judge noted Brand played no active role in the assault but shared responsibility because she left the teenager in the water, which led to drowning. Brand received a life sentence with a minimum term of 17 years but served less than three years before dying in custody the month before the memorial. Ringleader O’Brien and accomplice Kelly were sentenced to life with minimum terms of 22 years and 18 years respectively.
Official Response
A Scottish Prison Service spokesperson said:
> “Every death, whether in prison custody or in our communities, is a tragedy for all those who knew and supported the individual. When someone in our care dies, a service will often be held for those who knew and cared for the individual.”
The statement underscores the service’s intended purpose but does not address the staff’s forced participation.
Verbatim Quotes
- “Every death, whether in prison custody or in our communities, is a tragedy for all those who knew and supported the individual. When someone in our care dies, a service will often be held for those who knew and cared for the individual.” — Scottish Prison Service spokesperson
The controversy highlights tension between institutional protocols for honoring the deceased and the sensitivities of victims’ families and prison personnel.