Full Breakdown
Israeli Government Threatens Citizenship Revocation for Documentary Filmmakers Amid International Backlash
By Drooid · · How we work
Core Event: Threats and Legal Action Against *NAZA* Directors
Oscar-winning Israeli directors Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor faced threats after *NAZA* won the Special Jury Prize at the 83rd Venice International Film Festival. Culture Minister Miki Zohar announced he would seek to revoke their citizenship, calling the film “treason against the state.” National-security minister Itamar Ben-Gvir called the pair “a disgrace,” while Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu labeled the work “intolerable” and accused it of portraying the Israel Defense Forces as war criminals. IDF chief of staff Eyal Zamir said the military would use “every tool at our disposal” to counter what he termed “blood libels” and ordered a legal review.
Background & Context
*NAZA*—produced by a British newspaper and JW Films—derives its title from a Hebrew military abbreviation used to estimate civilian casualties in Gaza airstrikes. The 80-minute film presents 24 anonymously recorded testimonies from Israeli military and intelligence personnel describing AI-driven targeting systems and acceptance of high civilian death rates. The directors previously won an Oscar for *No Other Land*, which examined Palestinian resistance in the West Bank.
Timeline
- September 12, 2026 – *NAZA* receives a standing ovation and the Special Jury Prize at Venice.
- September 12, 2026 (later) – Zohar posts on X that he will act immediately to revoke the directors’ citizenship.
- September 14, 2026 – Broadcaster Yehuda Schlesinger urges viewers to “hunt” the filmmakers.
- September 15, 2026 – Over 200 Israeli filmmakers sign a petition supporting Abraham and Szor.
- Early September 2026 – 43 Israeli human-rights organizations issue a joint statement demanding an end to threats and legal action.
Official Statements & Responses
- Miki Zohar wrote to interior officials requesting a citizenship-revocation examination and an investigation into how the film’s material was obtained.
- Benjamin Netanyahu posted a video linking the directors to “anti-Israel” sentiment and accusing them of slandering IDF soldiers.
- Eyal Zamir announced that military lawyers are reviewing “possible legal measures.”
- The Committee to Protect Journalists called on Israeli authorities to reject any attempt to weaponize citizenship rights against journalists.
- A coalition of 43 NGOs—including Peace Now, Adalah, B’Tselem, Physicians for Human Rights Israel and Breaking the Silence—urged the government to cease incitement and refrain from prosecution.
Data & Statistics
- 43 human-rights organizations issued a joint statement.
- 1,500+ Israeli film-makers signed a petition; 200+ prominent directors added their names in a separate appeal.
- Gaza Health Ministry reports over 73,000 civilian deaths; the IDF estimates roughly 70,000.
- The documentary features 24 anonymous Israeli insiders; the title references the estimated number of civilians expected to die in a single strike.
On-the-Ground Reports
Far-right activists erected a mural in Ashdod depicting Abraham and Szor with crosshairs, horns and swastikas. A right-wing journalist shared a photograph of Abraham’s mother and solicited information about the director’s flight to facilitate “collateral damage” at the airport.
Conflicting Reports & Gaps
- Casualty figures differ between the Gaza Health Ministry (> 73,000) and the IDF (~70,000).
- The film alleges AI systems autonomously select targets, while the IDF maintains all strike decisions are made by human personnel and that the anonymous sources cannot be verified.
- No public screening of *NAZA* has occurred in Israel, leaving critics and supporters unable to assess the film’s evidence directly.