Story perspectives

Thirlwall Inquiry Finds Complete Failure Protecting Babies at Hospital

By Drooid · Sep 17, 2026, 2:00 PM UTC · How we work

Summary

Thirlwall Inquiry Finds Failure

The Thirlwall Inquiry found a complete failure to protect babies at the Countess of Chester Hospital.
Lady Justice Thirlwall said hospital management was dysfunctional, creating a gulf between leaders and clinicians.
Senior nurses ignored consultants’ 2015-2016 concerns and delayed notifying police.
CQC chief inspector Dr Toli Onon admitted regulator’s record-keeping fell short at the hospital.

Summary

McDonald Submits Reports

Defence lawyer Mark McDonald submitted 30 expert reports to the Criminal Cases Review Commission.
The CCRC is reviewing Letby’s case for a Court of Appeal referral.
Three former hospital executives were arrested on suspicion of corporate manslaughter linked to the case.
An international panel of 30 experts has challenged the forensic evidence used at Letby’s trial.
The defence argues the inquiry’s conclusions are tainted by trial errors and assumed guilt.

History

Historical Context

The 1984-1995 Bristol Royal Infirmary heart scandal, exposed by whistle-blower Steve Bolsin and investigated by the Kennedy Inquiry (set up 1998, report 2001), revealed staff shortages and an ‘old-boy’ culture that likely caused 170 child deaths. The Department of Health’s 2001 reforms on clinical governance now echo in the Thirlwall Inquiry into the Countess of Chester Hospital, highlighting ongoing oversight gaps.

1 of 3

Thirlwall Inquiry Finds Failure

The Thirlwall Inquiry found a complete failure to protect babies at the Countess of Chester Hospital.
Lady Justice Thirlwall said hospital management was dysfunctional, creating a gulf between leaders and clinicians.
Senior nurses ignored consultants’ 2015-2016 concerns and delayed notifying police.
CQC chief inspector Dr Toli Onon admitted regulator’s record-keeping fell short at the hospital.

1 / 3