Full Breakdown
$40 Million Arbitration Award After Uber Driver Leaves Passenger on Freeway
By Drooid · · How we work
Arbitration Verdict and Award
A five-day arbitration in Orange County concluded that Uber and driver Vu Tran were jointly and severally liable for the death of 23-year-old Emily Normandin-Parker. Retired Judge Richard A. Stone described the drop-off location on State Route 73 as an “unsafe and illegal” gore point and noted that Tran could have used the nearby MacArthur Boulevard exit. The award totals $40 million: $20 million to each of Emily’s parents, Carol Normandin and Ken Parker, and $300 000 to her friend Luna Moore. No punitive damages were granted.
Driver Conduct and Prior Complaints
Evidence presented showed Tran knew the passengers were intoxicated and argued with Moore over a cleaning fee before ejecting them. GPS data indicated Tran drove past Emily’s body before exiting and contacting Uber to pursue the fee. The arbitrator found these complaints demonstrated a pattern of dangerous behavior.
Uber’s Legal Position and Response
The company contested the arbitrator’s finding, maintaining that the decision was legally incorrect. Uber argued that it is “merely a technology company” and invoked Proposition 22—a 2020 California ballot measure classifying app-based drivers as independent contractors—to claim it should not be held liable. The arbitrator rejected both arguments, concluding that Uber provides transportation services, sets prices, and controls key aspects of the rider experience, making it a common carrier.
Foundation and Ongoing Safety Advocacy
Following the award, the Normandin-Parker family announced the creation of the Emily Normandin-Parker Foundation, dedicated to promoting ride-hailing safety and corporate accountability. Proceeds from the arbitration will fund the foundation’s activities, which aim to push for stricter safety protocols and greater transparency from ride-share platforms.
Verbatim Quotes
- “He chose to pull over there and demand money and kick them out of the car. All I can think that Emily was doing -- her friend, the driver arguing -- was to get help. They argue, Emily gets hit while they're arguing,” — Carol Normandin
- “We didn't have much time to absorb the award before Uber almost immediately started contending that it could not be made public and then sent an agreement to us requiring non-disparagement, the $10 million penalty for saying anything bad about Uber,” — Ken Parker
- “And she was funny. And she could sing. Oh my god, could she sing,” — Carol Normandin