Story perspectives

Juror Rejects Insanity Verdict, Judge Declares Mistrial

By Drooid · Sep 18, 2026, 12:00 PM UTC · How we work

Summary

Story summary

Juror Michael P. Desronvil refused an insanity verdict, prompting Judge William Sullivan to declare a mistrial on Sept 4.
Desronvil said he had no doubts that Lindsay Clancy knowingly planned the killings.
The 12-member jury remained deadlocked 11-1, preventing a unanimous verdict.
A hearing on the case is scheduled for Sept 29 at Plymouth Superior Court.
District Attorney Timothy Cruz has not announced a retrial.

History

Historical Context

In 1995, the O.J. Simpson criminal trial concluded with a not-guilty verdict after a 12-member jury deliberated 11 days. Prosecutor Marcia Clark presented over $33 million in forensic evidence, while defense attorney Johnnie Cochran secured a 52 percent public approval poll. Like the 2024 Plymouth case where juror Michael P. Desronvil rejected an insanity verdict, the Simpson trial demonstrated how single juror convictions can tip a deadlocked panel. The precedent underscores courts’ reliance on retrials or mistrials, prompting district attorneys such as Timothy Cruz to weigh re-prosecution strategies.

1 of 2

Story summary

Juror Michael P. Desronvil refused an insanity verdict, prompting Judge William Sullivan to declare a mistrial on Sept 4.
Desronvil said he had no doubts that Lindsay Clancy knowingly planned the killings.
The 12-member jury remained deadlocked 11-1, preventing a unanimous verdict.
A hearing on the case is scheduled for Sept 29 at Plymouth Superior Court.
District Attorney Timothy Cruz has not announced a retrial.

1 / 2