Full Breakdown
Israeli Families Abroad Face Complex Legal Landscape
By Drooid · · How we work
Background & Context
Emigration among Israelis has accelerated. A Central Bureau of Statistics release published in September 2024 classified 55,300 Israelis as long-term emigrants in its 2023 cohort, up from about 38,000 a year earlier. A Knesset Research and Information Center report listed 59,400 emigrants in 2022, 82,800 in 2023 and a provisional 69,500 in 2024. The Institute for Jewish Policy Research estimated roughly 630,000 Israelis or former residents lived abroad during 2021-2023; adding an estimated 325,000 children born abroad brings the broader “Israel-connected” population to about 955,000.
Core Legal Issues
Child Habitual Residence and the Hague Convention
When families move overseas, the decisive question is the child’s habitual residence—the country that has become the practical centre of the child’s life. Israeli family-law specialist Judith Meisels explains that courts examine where the child wakes up, attends school, and how settled the family appears, as well as the parents’ last shared plan. The 1980 Hague Convention on international child abduction, ratified by over 100 nations, seeks the return of children wrongfully removed from their habitual residence but does not resolve custody. Courts may refuse return if there is a grave-risk exception, i.e., a real danger of physical or psychological harm to the child.
Divorce Across Jurisdictions
A move abroad can split a divorce between civil courts in the country of residence and Israeli rabbinical courts for couples married under Jewish law. Israeli law permits rabbinical courts to hear certain “get-refusal” cases involving spouses abroad, but only under narrowly defined circumstances. Meisels notes that many Israelis abroad feel isolated, lack language skills, and have limited legal support, complicating cross-border divorce proceedings.
Property and Inheritance
Property disputes raise questions of jurisdiction and applicable law. Israeli law generally applies the law of the country where the couple made their home at the time of marriage, not necessarily the country of the wedding. Foreign judgments must be declared enforceable by an Israeli court before execution in Israel. For families with assets in multiple countries, Meisels advises preparing separate wills in each jurisdiction or a single Israeli will that identifies foreign assets, while ensuring coordination to avoid conflict.
Official Statements & Responses
Israeli law defines a child’s habitual residence through a factual test that considers the child’s daily environment and parental intent. The law also stipulates that the law of the country where the marital home was established governs property division in divorce, and that foreign court orders require Israeli validation. Meisels repeatedly advises families to document the purpose and expected duration of any overseas move, retain written agreements, and seek legal counsel before departure, especially when the move follows periods of conflict such as the post-Oct. 7 war.
Conflicting Reports & Gaps
The Portuguese child-return case illustrates divergent judicial outcomes. An Israeli mother traveled to Portugal with her six-year-old daughter on October 17, 2023 after both parents agreed the child would leave Israel temporarily following the Oct. 7 attack. The father later invoked the Hague Convention to seek the child’s return.
- The Lisbon trial court initially declined to order return.
- The Lisbon Court of Appeal reversed that decision, finding the war insufficient to meet the grave-risk exception and ordering return.
- Portugal’s Supreme Court denied the return request on November 26, 2024.
These opposing rulings underscore the lack of uniformity in applying the grave-risk exception and highlight the uncertainty families face when courts in different jurisdictions interpret the same facts differently.