Full Breakdown
Judge Denies New Trial for Maui Doctor Convicted of Attempted Manslaughter
By Drooid · · How we work
Trial Verdict and Appeal Request
In April, a Honolulu jury found Dr. Gerhardt Konig guilty of attempted manslaughter for an assault on his wife that occurred on an Oahu hiking trail. Following the verdict, Konig’s attorney, Thomas Otake, filed a motion seeking a new trial, arguing that juror comments to the media indicated a misunderstanding of the judge’s instructions and that a juror may have communicated with an outside observer watching a livestream of the proceedings.
Allegations of Jury Misconduct
The defense’s motion centered on two alleged issues: (1) jurors reportedly made public statements that suggested they had not fully grasped the legal standards for conviction, and a possible breach of deliberation secrecy through a livestream. To address these claims, Circuit Court Judge Paul Wong summoned each juror for individual questioning. All jurors affirmed that they had not discussed the case with anyone outside the deliberation room.
Judicial Ruling
He further noted that the language of the post failed to rise to the level of “specific substantial evidence” required to demonstrate bias. Consequently, the judge denied the request for a new trial. The defense indicated it will pursue an appeal of the decision.
Verbatim Quotes
- “Just because 12 jurors come in here five months later in a public setting and deny wrongdoing doesn’t prove it beyond a reasonable doubt, doesn’t meet the state’s burden. The state should do more and produce more,” — Thomas Otake
Next Steps
Konig’s sentencing is scheduled for early 2027, with a potential penalty of up to 20 years in prison. The appeal process will determine whether the conviction remains in force pending that future sentencing.