Full Breakdown
St. Thomas Railway City Faces Decay Amid National Rail Shifts
By Drooid · · How we work
The Declining Hub
St. Thomas, Ontario, once a bustling railway junction where eight lines converged, is now “the Railway City” without any active rail service. The former Michigan Central Railway Locomotive Shops—built in 1913, once staffed by 400 workers, and one of three surviving structures from a complex of 112 buildings—now house the Elgin County Railway Museum, which has been closed to the public because its walls are bowing and the ceiling is unsafe. Local activist Wil Zufelt, who leads the nonprofit Railworks, is launching an $8 million fundraising campaign to restore the shops and turn them into a community gathering space. Across the city, abandoned tracks, rusted spikes and a missing rail connection—ordered for reconstruction by a 1990 federal transport directive—remain visible reminders of the lost network.
Historical Context and National Trends
St. Thomas’s prominence stemmed from its position on the Detroit-Buffalo and New York-Chicago corridors, even hosting a U.S. consulate in its heyday. As automobiles and trucks captured passenger and freight traffic, railways abandoned unprofitable routes, often dismantling tracks and selling rails for scrap. Historian Thomas Blampied notes that decisions to remove infrastructure “made economic sense” as the rail era receded. Across Canada, similar patterns have left many communities with fragmented rail corridors, complicating current efforts to revive passenger service on a network that was reshaped for freight.
Official Perspectives
Thomas Blampied emphasizes the dilemma of preserving legacy infrastructure versus the cost of maintaining unused tracks, signals and crossing warnings. Transportation policy expert Anthony Perl argues that Canada’s rail companies retain control over the tracks, shaping whether they are kept or removed, and that this ownership makes it unlikely a parallel rail system will ever be built.
Verbatim Quotes
- “Do we keep the infrastructure — so the track, all the signals, all the crossing warnings — do we keep it all intact?” — Thomas Blampied, a historian — Thomas Blampied, historian
- “We had a great streamlining, or right-sizing, or value engineering, pick your term — of the national rail infrastructure in Canada as passenger trains went away,” — Anthony Perl, a transportation policy expert at Simon Fraser University — Anthony Perl, transportation policy expert at Simon Fraser University
- “No one is going to build an alternative set of rails across this country under any circumstances,” — Anthony Perl, a transportation policy expert at Simon Fraser University — Anthony Perl, transportation policy expert at Simon Fraser University
Future Outlook
Railworks’ fundraising effort seeks to secure the $8 million needed for structural repairs and adaptive reuse of the locomotive shops. The Canadian Transportation Agency confirms that the 1990 order requiring CN to replace the missing diamond connection remains in effect, though CN has not indicated plans to act. Meanwhile, federal and provincial initiatives—such as the proposed high-speed “Alto” line between Toronto and Quebec City and the revival of the Northlander service—highlight a national interest in restoring passenger rail, even as legacy corridors like St. Thomas’s await resolution.