Full Breakdown
Former Ohio Lawyer Sentenced for Attempted Murder at Toledo Restaurant
By Drooid · · How we work
Attempted Shooting at Sabira Restaurant
On April 11, 2025, former attorney Matthew Exton, 43, entered the Sabira restaurant in downtown Toledo and pointed a Colt Defender handgun at his ex-wife, who was seated with her mother. The weapon failed to discharge because its safety was engaged. Waitstaff and other patrons tackled Exton, preventing any injuries. Surveillance video shown at trial captured Exton charging toward the pair with the gun drawn.
Trial, Conviction, and Sentencing
Exton was convicted earlier this month of two counts of attempted murder and two counts of felonious assault. He faced sentencing enhancements under Ohio law for using a firearm during the felonies. Representing himself, Exton told Judge Gary Cook that he did not intend to kill or harm anyone and framed the incident as politically motivated. Cook, after reviewing the video evidence, sentenced Exton to a term of up to 24 ½ years in prison, emphasizing the need to protect victims and the public.
Official Statements & Responses
Judge Cook highlighted a moment in the footage where Exton appeared to scramble to disengage the safety lever, reinforcing the court’s view that the defendant’s actions were reckless and intentional.
Verbatim Quotes
Key Figures
- Matthew Exton – former lawyer, defendant; convicted of attempted murder and felonious assault.
- Mike Loisel – Lucas County Prosecutor, who sought a long prison term.
- Gary Cook – Lucas County Common Pleas Court judge who imposed the sentence.
The sentencing reflects the court’s assessment that Exton’s conduct endangered multiple patrons and underscores Ohio’s strict penalties for firearm-related felonies.