Full Breakdown
SNP Leadership Rejects Grassroots Amendment on Independence Strategy
By Drooid · · How we work
Core Event
At a recent National Executive Committee (NEC) meeting, SNP leader John Swinney and deputy leader Keith Brown dismissed a draft amendment that had been supported by more than 50 party branches and affiliates. The amendment called for a consensus-building national campaign and for using the next general election as a decisive vote on Scotland’s “right to choose.” National Secretary Alex Kerr cast the deciding vote to block the proposal, prompting reports of a tense atmosphere among attending members.
Background & Context
Party insiders note that the SNP has lost 60 % of its membership since 2019, a decline they say weakens grassroots influence. Earlier internal disputes, such as a 2021 leaked NEC meeting over party finances, are cited as precedents for the current friction. The rejected amendment was part of a broader push by activists who view Swinney’s independence approach as “too timid” and insufficient to win over undecided or “No” voters.
Official Statements & Responses
Swanney and Brown defended the leadership’s stance, emphasizing a £100,000 “war chest” intended to fund a “hearts-and-minds” independence campaign. A party spokesman reiterated that independence will be central to the upcoming Aberdeen conference, that a “historic Cardiff Agreement” has been reached, and that the First Minister plans to hold a referendum within the next five years.
Grassroots Criticism & Opposition
Activists who backed the amendment argue that the leadership’s rejection signals a de-prioritisation of independence, especially given the party’s recent membership losses. Some described the £100,000 allocation as barely enough for leaflets and advertisements, labeling it a symbolic gesture rather than a serious investment. Others criticized recent outreach, such as the Celtic Alliance summit in Cardiff, as “performative” and insufficient for engaging undecided voters.
Implications for the Independence Campaign
The clash highlights a growing divide between the SNP’s parliamentary leadership and its grassroots base over strategy and resource allocation. While the leadership points to funding and upcoming legislative moves as evidence of commitment, activists warn that without broader member engagement the party risks alienating the very supporters it needs to secure a future referendum.