Full Breakdown
Alleged $5 Million Extortion Claim Examined by NSW ICAC
By Drooid · · How we work
Background & Context
The dispute centres on fugitive property developer Jean Nassif, who built several high-rise projects through the construction firm Toplace. In 2021 Toplace executives, including former executive Sharangan Macheswaran, raised concerns with then-building commissioner David Chandler about defects at the Skyview development. Allegations later emerged that Nassif was pressured to pay a $5 million sum to secure the removal of a prohibition order Chandler could impose. The NSW Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC) opened “Operation Rosny” to investigate possible extortion and related misconduct.
Core Event: ICAC Hearing on September 14 2026
On Monday, September 14, 2026, Nassif appeared before ICAC via video link from Beirut. Maheswaran presented text messages exchanged between Nassif and contractor Navid Ardestani. The messages referenced a $5 million bank cheque and an additional $250 000 for painting and rendering work, which Maheswaran described as evidence of an extortion attempt.
Data & Statistics
- $5 million – amount Nassif was alleged to have been asked to provide.
- $250 000 – additional amount mentioned for painting and rendering.
- Eight weeks – projected duration of public hearings.
Official Statements & Responses
- Navid Ardestani denied any threat, saying he was seeking payment for work already completed.
- David Chandler testified that he was offered to accompany a Toplace representative to police regarding the alleged demand, but he denied wrongdoing and said he would have referred any evidence of a shakedown to law-enforcement.
- Sharangan Macheswaran maintained that the texts indicated a threat, even though the threat was not explicit, and suggested the alleged extortion was a tactic to pressure Chandler.
Conflicting Reports & Gaps
Sources differ on whether the text exchange constitutes genuine extortion or a straightforward payment request for remediation:
- ABC frames the exchange as a “lie” and a request for payment, quoting Dr Dwyer’s assessment that the claim of extortion is false.
- The Age describes the allegation as a “trumped-up” extortion attempt designed to damage Chandler before a prohibition order could be issued.
- SMH notes that Maheswaran’s notes omitted Ardestani’s confusion about Nassif’s claim that he could “control the government,” suggesting selective recording.
No police complaint was filed, and Ardestani is not accused of wrongdoing. The commission has not yet determined whether prohibited political donations were exchanged for favours.
Verbatim Quotes
- “What I'm putting to you puts a lie to your claim that this was an extortion. This is clearly a request for payment so that remediation works can take place on Jean Nassif's building,” — Dr Dwyer
- “We don't make threats, and we never did… and also, we don't do anything illegal,” — Mr Ardestani
- “I'm told you control the government, the commissioner, and the ministers," Mr Nassif said.” — Mr Nassif
- “Mr Nassif was taking this very, very seriously, was contemplating paying $5 million to these people,” — Sharangan Macheswaran, former Toplace executive