Missouri Substitute Teacher Suspended Over OnlyFans Content

Sheena Sittner, a substitute teacher in the Ballwin, Missouri school district, has worked as an adult-content creator on OnlyFans for more than two years. After the contractor that placed her in the district, Kelly Education, discovered the online profile, the district placed her on suspension and issued a warning that she must not contact any school or district in a professional capacity. Sittner, who also has a child enrolled in the same district, said she anticipated the discovery but did not expect the employment consequences.

The Hill

The contractor’s email warned that continued contact could jeopardize her employment, pending termination.

The Hill

• “If teachers were paid better, women wouldn’t have to resort to online content creation,” — Sheena Sittner, school district spokesman

The Hill

• “It’s funny because I’ve had this account, this OnlyFans account, for two-plus years,” — Sheena Sittner, school district spokesman

The Hill

• “So, whoever did find it did some deep-dive digging, because two years later and now it’s being found out.” — Sheena Sittner, school district spokesman

The Hill

• “It’s like all of a sudden I’ve done something so wrong and sinful that I’m not even allowed volunteer at his school,” — Sheena Sittner, school district spokesman

The Hill

• “It does not, and cannot, limit anyone’s right as a parent. Nothing in our request restricts their participation in their child’s education.” — Sheena Sittner, school district spokesman

The Hill

The incident highlights the tension between personal online activities and employment expectations for educators, especially when contractors are involved in hiring. While the district maintains that parental rights remain intact, the suspension underscores how schools may enforce conduct standards that extend beyond classroom duties. Sittner noted she can seek other employment and handle public criticism, but she draws a line when the issue affects her child’s schooling. The case may prompt other districts to review policies on off-duty conduct and the scope of contractor-issued warnings.

The Hill