Full Breakdown
Mina Kimes Calls Out a Perceived Double Standard in Stephen A. Smith’s Coverage of Dak Prescott
By Drooid · · How we work
Core Critique of Double Standard
Mina Kimes argued that ESPN analyst Stephen A. Smith places disproportionate blame on Dallas Cowboys quarterback Dak Prescott and the team’s offense when the Cowboys miss the playoffs, while offering more lenient explanations for Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow when his team struggles behind a weak defense. Kimes contended that the math “ain’t mathing” when the Cowboys field a top-10 offense but a defense ranked near the bottom of the league.
Cowboys’ Offensive and Defensive Rankings
The Cowboys’ offense ranks among the league’s top ten in total production, yet the defense is listed 30th in yards allowed (387 yards per game) and points allowed (27.3 points per game). An NFL Live analyst highlighted that the defense is 32nd in success rate and 30th in expected points added per play (EPA/play). The team’s 1-2 record follows a 34-31 loss to the Baltimore Ravens in Brazil.
Media Commentary and Responses
Stephen A. Smith, during a Thursday edition of *First Take*, asserted that the Cowboys’ offense should bear responsibility if the team fails to meet expectations. In response, Kimes questioned why the offense would be singled out when the defense ranks among the league’s worst, suggesting that any playoff shortfall would more logically be attributed to the defensive unit.
Verbatim Quotes
- “I just want to make sure I'm following this correctly,” — Mina Kimes
- “I have seen you with my own two eyes and ears make the opposite case for Joe Burrow. 'Oh, that awful defense in Cincinnati is the reason why Joseph Burrow isn’t in the playoffs and making Super Bowl runs. I feel this is a double standard for this quarterback (Prescott) compared to others who are saddled with awful defenses,” — Mina Kimes
- “The question isn’t just what happened in that one game. It’s if the Cowboys falter, who deserves the most blame? ... It is so obviously going to be the defense,” — Mina Kimes
Playoff Implications
Kimes emphasized that the upcoming matchup against the Houston Texans will test whether Prescott can succeed with a defense that statistically lags far behind the offense. She warned that if the Cowboys miss the postseason, public and analyst scrutiny is likely to focus on the defensive shortcomings rather than the quarterback’s performance.