Story perspectives

Massachusetts Man Indicted for Cyberstalking Stephen Miller’s Wife

By Drooid · Oct 2, 2026, 4:43 PM UTC · How we work

Summary

Proia Arrested

U.S. prosecutors arrested Massachusetts man John Anthony Proia III for cyberstalking Katie Miller, Stephen Miller’s wife.
A federal grand jury indicted Proia on one count of cyberstalking on Thursday.
Proia allegedly sent at least 40 calls and texts to Miller and her parents between Aug. 3 and Sept. 23.
Two senior Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) counterterrorism officials were demoted after concerns about the probe’s handling.

Summary

Andrew Bailey Resigns

FBI Deputy Director Andrew Bailey resigned after disagreeing with the decision to demote two senior counterterrorism agents.
Prosecutors reported internal DOJ doubts that the case met federal threats statutes and urged local police handling.
Two senior FBI counterterrorism officials pushed back, saying the probe fell outside their Middle East mandate.
The indictment notes John Anthony Proia III, a veteran, used VoIP apps to generate phone numbers and mask his identity.

Summary

Leah Foley Tested

Prosecutors say a pending charge will test Boston’s U.S. attorney’s office’s reputation for independent vetting.
Leah Foley, a career line prosecutor, has cultivated strong rapport with Trump-aligned DOJ officials.
Foley’s district has avoided staffing exodus and morale decline seen in other Trump-loyalist U.S. attorney offices.
The Justice Department has broadened application of the interstate threats statute, 18 U.S.C. § 875, during this administration.

History

Historical Context

In 1996, the FBI launched the Computer Crime and Intellectual Property Section (CCIPS) to combat emerging cyber offenses, marking a pivotal shift in federal law enforcement. CCIPS began with 30 specially trained agents, allowing coordinated investigations across states and abroad. Today, the Proia cyberstalking case tests that framework as FBI Deputy Director Andrew Bailey resigns over demotions tied to a probe that stretched CCIPS’s original Middle-East mandate. The episode underscores how the 1996 cyber-crime initiative still shapes DOJ’s expanding use of 18 U.S.C. § 875, influencing future prosecutorial independence.

1 of 4

Proia Arrested

U.S. prosecutors arrested Massachusetts man John Anthony Proia III for cyberstalking Katie Miller, Stephen Miller’s wife.
A federal grand jury indicted Proia on one count of cyberstalking on Thursday.
Proia allegedly sent at least 40 calls and texts to Miller and her parents between Aug. 3 and Sept. 23.
Two senior Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) counterterrorism officials were demoted after concerns about the probe’s handling.

1 / 4