Full Breakdown
Supreme Court to Review Colorado Preschool Funding Dispute
By Drooid · · How we work
Core Event
The U.S. Supreme Court will hear St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy, a First Amendment challenge to Colorado’s Universal Preschool Program, which funds preschools that follow a nondiscrimination policy covering sexual orientation and gender identity. Two Catholic parishes—St. Mary in Littleton and St. Bernadette in Lakewood—argue the policy violates their free-exercise rights.
Background & Context
Colorado has been a focal point for clashes between religious liberty and LGBTQ protections. The 1996 Romer v. Evans decision struck down a state amendment that barred such protections. More recently, the Court has sided with religious claimants in cases like Masterpiece Cakeshop (2018) and 303 Creative v. Elenis (2023). Earlier in 2026, the Court found Colorado’s ban on “conversion therapy” to be viewpoint discrimination in Chiles v. Salazar. All three cases were litigated by the Alliance Defending Freedom, which also represents the plaintiffs here.
Key Figures & Groups
- St. Mary Catholic Parish – Plaintiff.
- St. Bernadette Catholic Parish – Co-plaintiff.
- Alliance Defending Freedom – Legal counsel.
- Colorado Department of Education – Administrator of the preschool program.
Timeline of Relevant Cases
- 1992 – Colorado voters approve an amendment limiting LGBTQ anti-discrimination protections.
- 1996 – *Romer v. Evans* overturns the amendment.
- 2018 – *Masterpiece Cakeshop* vacates rulings against a baker refusing a same-sex cake.
- 2023 – *303 Creative* upholds a web designer’s refusal to serve same-sex couples.
- Early 2026 – *Chiles v. Salazar* rules Colorado’s conversion-therapy ban discriminatory.
- 2026 (term beginning Oct.) – Court agrees to hear *St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy*; oral arguments scheduled for the term.
Why It Matters
The case tests whether a state-funded early-education program can require compliance with LGBTQ nondiscrimination standards. A ruling for the parishes could expand religious-freedom exemptions for institutions receiving public money; a decision upholding the policy would reinforce the condition that public funds carry nondiscrimination obligations.
Official Positions & Responses
- Colorado officials say the state will defend the universal preschool law, emphasizing its role in expanding early-childhood education while protecting LGBTQ families.
Conflicting Perspectives & Gaps
The article lacks statements from LGBTQ advocacy groups and data on how many preschools could be affected. The Court has not indicated whether it will address the broader issue of public-funding conditions versus religious objections, leaving that question for oral arguments.