Full Breakdown
Doctors and Insurers Sue Gov. Gavin Newsom Over New California Health Tax
By Drooid · · How we work
Lawsuit Over the Managed Care Organization Tax
Doctors and health-insurers have filed a complaint with the California Supreme Court alleging that Governor Gavin Newsom and the state legislature violated Proposition 35, the 2024 voter-approved initiative that limits health-care taxes. The suit was brought by the California Medical Association and the California Association of Health Plans, which contend that the recently enacted managed care organization (MCO) tax circumvents the initiative’s restrictions and could raise private-plan premiums by about $100 per enrollee each year—roughly $400 for a family of four.
Background: Proposition 35 and Prior Tax Structure
Proposition 35, approved by 68 % of voters in 2024, set a ceiling on health-care taxes and earmarked any revenue for Medi-Cal improvements. For more than two decades California has levied lower-rate taxes on private insurers than on Medi-Cal providers to fund the state’s low-income health program. In June, the Legislature passed a bill that substantially increased the tax on private plans, a move the state justified as a response to large-scale federal Medi-Cal funding cuts.
Financial Impact on Consumers
Health-insurers estimate the MCO tax will add $8.85 per month per enrollee, translating to the $100-per-person annual increase cited in the lawsuit. The association of insurers warns that the added cost will be passed directly to consumers, inflating family premiums by roughly $400 each year on top of typical yearly rate hikes.
Official Statements & Responses
State officials maintain that the tax is necessary to address budget shortfalls and to fund Medi-Cal under the constraints of federal regulations. A spokesperson for the Department of Finance said the administration is trying to balance affordability for privately insured patients against the impact of federal Medi-Cal cuts. Governor Newsom, who did not oppose Proposition 35 when it was on the ballot, previously warned that the initiative could “hamstring” the state budget.
Verbatim Quotes
- “The state disagrees with their claims, and we believe the courts will too,” — Tara Gallegos, a spokesperson for Newsom
- “California is breaking the law by blowing through a tax limit voters put in place to protect Californians and businesses from higher health care costs,” — Charles Bacchi, CEO of the health plans association
- “California should not resolve its budget shortfall by imposing a massive tax increase on health care costs for working families,” — Charles Bacchi, CEO of the health plans association
- “This lawsuit is about a simple principle: the state has to follow the law,” — Dustin Corcoran, medical association CEO