Full Breakdown
Sen. Susan Collins Faces Scrutiny Over 2018 Kavanaugh Confirmation and Roe v. Wade Overturn
By Drooid · · How we work
Election Context and Collins’ Position
Republican Sen. Susan Collins is in a tight 2024 Senate race in Maine against Democratic challenger Troy Jackson. Throughout the campaign, Collins has been questioned about her 2018 vote to confirm Justice Brett Kavanaugh. She describes herself as “pro-choice” and has repeatedly said she “does not regret” that vote, while asserting that the 2022 Dobbs decision overturning *Roe v. Wade* was inevitable because the Court voted 6-3. The claim about a 6-3 margin is contradicted by the record that the decision was reached by a 5-4 vote, making Kavanaugh’s vote decisive.
Kavanaugh Confirmation and *Roe* Overturn Background
President Donald Trump had pledged to nominate judges who would do so. After Kavanaugh joined the Court’s conservative majority, the 2022 *Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization* ruling overturned the 1973 *Roe* precedent, allowing states to impose severe bans and restrictions on abortion.
Collins’ Statements on the Decision
During a recent interview with Maine ABC affiliate WMTW, Collins expressed disappointment with the outcome: “I’m very disappointed in his vote to overturn Roe v. Wade,” — Republican Sen. Susan Collins She added that she had not anticipated the vote, despite having been warned in 2018 that Kavanaugh might seek to overturn *Roe*. Collins has also defended her earlier stance by saying, “Suffice it to say, prominent advocacy organizations have been wrong.” “Suffice it to say, prominent advocacy organizations have been wrong,” — Republican Sen. Susan Collins
Planned Parenthood Response
Lisa Margulies, spokesperson for Planned Parenthood Votes in Maine, called Collins’s explanations “a flat-out lie” and accused her of avoiding responsibility: “This is just another flimsy attempt to avoid responsibility for her actions,” — Lisa Margulies, spokesperson for Planned Parenthood Votes in Maine Margulies argued that Mainers had traveled to Washington, D.C., to oppose Kavanaugh because they recognized the direct threat to abortion rights.
Why It Matters
The controversy highlights how a single Senate confirmation vote can shape national policy for decades. As Collins’s re-election hinges on voters’ views of her role in the *Roe* overturn, the dispute underscores the political stakes of judicial appointments and the enduring impact of the 2022 Supreme Court decision.