Full Breakdown
Players Who Appear in Multiple Clubs’ All-Time Top-10 Scoring Charts
By Drooid · · How we work
Core Finding: Multi-Club Top-10 Scorers
The Guardian’s Knowledge archive identified a set of footballers who rank among the all-time top-10 goal-scorers for more than one club. Dozens of players feature for two clubs, including Sergio Agüero (Atlético Madrid and Manchester City) and Kenny Dalglish (Celtic and Liverpool). The article highlights a smaller group that reaches the top-10 for three or more clubs, establishing a distinct tier of multi-club scoring achievement.
Notable Players with Three or More Clubs
- Romário – appears in the top-10 for Vasco da Gama, Flamengo and PSV.
- Delio Onnis – listed among the top-10 for Monaco, Tours FC and Gimnasia; his record for Toulon could not be confirmed.
- Robbie Keane – ranks in the top-10 for Tottenham, LA Galaxy and ATK.
- André-Pierre Gignac – featured in the top-10 for Marseille, Toulouse and Tigres UANL.
- John Aldridge – holds top-10 spots for Newport County, Oxford United and Tranmere Rovers.
- Samuel Eto’o – potentially in the top-10 for Mallorca, Barcelona, Anzhi Makhachkala and Antalyaspor (the Antalyaspor record is unverified).
- Sam Kerr – likely among the top-10 for five clubs: Perth Glory FC, Western New York Flash, Gotham FC, Chicago Red Stars and Chelsea.
Unique Cases and Records
- Harry Johnson – scored 201 league goals for Sheffield United (1919-1931) and 104 for Mansfield over three seasons, making him the all-time top scorer for every club he represented, a possibly unique record for a player with multiple clubs.
- Abderrazak Hamdallah – is the all-time top scorer for OC Safi (Morocco), second for El-Jaish (Qatar), fourth for Guangzhou R&F/Guangzhou City (China), fourth for Al-Nassr, seventh for Al-Ittihad and 10th for Al-Shabab (Saudi Arabia). At 35, he has recently joined Al-Taawoun, leaving open the prospect of adding another club to his list.
Data Summary
- Players with two-club top-10 status number in the dozens.
- Those with three-club status include Romário, Delio Onnis, Robbie Keane, André-Pierre Gignac and John Aldridge.
- Four-club candidates are Samuel Eto’o (with one unverified entry) and Sam Kerr (five clubs).
- Six-club status is claimed for Abderrazak Hamdallah, pending future verification.
These findings illustrate the rarity of sustained high-scoring performance across multiple teams, with only a handful of footballers achieving top-10 placement for three or more clubs in their careers.