Story perspectives

Judge Returns, But Yankees Struggle in Crucial Loss

9/6/2025

Summary

Story summary

Aaron Judge returned to right field for the New York Yankees on September 5, 2025, after a flexor strain.
He played all nine innings in a 7-1 loss to the Toronto Blue Jays, raising concerns about his arm strength.
Judge refrained from throwing home on a key play, allowing two runs for Toronto.
Manager Aaron Boone stated Judge won't play right field daily, balancing health and Giancarlo Stanton's role.
The Yankees trail the Blue Jays by four games in the AL East, making this series crucial for playoffs.

History

Historical Context

In 2019, the New York Yankees faced a significant injury crisis, with key players Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton sidelined, yet they achieved a 103-win season. Despite their success, they exited the playoffs early, prompting management to invest over $200 million in player contracts. Judge's return raises ongoing concerns about player durability and the team's performance in the competitive AL East.

1 of 2

Story summary

Aaron Judge returned to right field for the New York Yankees on September 5, 2025, after a flexor strain.
He played all nine innings in a 7-1 loss to the Toronto Blue Jays, raising concerns about his arm strength.
Judge refrained from throwing home on a key play, allowing two runs for Toronto.
Manager Aaron Boone stated Judge won't play right field daily, balancing health and Giancarlo Stanton's role.
The Yankees trail the Blue Jays by four games in the AL East, making this series crucial for playoffs.

1 / 2