Aaron Judge Returns to Outfield Amidst Injury Concerns

New York Yankees captain Aaron Judge made his long-awaited return to right field on September 5, 2025, against the Toronto Blue Jays, marking his first appearance in the outfield since July 25 due to a right flexor strain. Judge had been limited to designated hitter duties since coming off the injured list on August 5, following a 10-day recovery period. His return coincided with a critical series against the Blue Jays, who were leading the American League East by four games over the Yankees.

ESPNYankees’ Aaron Judge back at DH vs. Blue Jays after outfield returnYankees’ Aaron Judge set to make long-awaited outfield returnCBS SportsABC7 New YorkAaron Judge throws gingerly in first outfield appearance since July 25, but insists arm is 100%Yankees’ captain returns to right field ahead of AL East showdown

In the Yankees' 7-1 loss to the Blue Jays, Judge played all nine innings but raised immediate concerns about his throwing ability. In the first inning, with the bases loaded, Judge opted to make a short throw to second base after fielding a single from Nathan Lukes, allowing Daulton Varsho to score from third without a play at home. Statcast measured Judge's throw at just 67.9 mph, leading to questions about his arm strength. Judge defended his decision, stating, “I wouldn’t be in the outfield if I wasn’t able to make that throw,” and emphasized the importance of getting the ball to the cutoff man.

Yankees’ Aaron Judge makes major statement after right field returnAaron Judge throws gingerly in first outfield appearance since July 25, but insists arm is 100%Yankees' Aaron Judge faces heat for not trying to make throw to plate vs. Blue JaysABC7 New YorkHeavyCBS SportsYankees' Aaron Judge returns to right field against Blue Jays

Yankees manager Aaron Boone expressed cautious optimism about Judge's return, indicating that Judge would not play right field every day initially. Boone noted that the team would monitor Judge's performance closely, stating, “He’s in position to make the throw,” but did not elaborate on why Judge chose not to attempt the throw home. Boone's strategy involves alternating Judge and Giancarlo Stanton between right field and designated hitter roles to manage their health and maximize offensive output.

EssentiallySportsYankees’ Aaron Judge makes major statement after right field returnABC7 New YorkYankees have a big new plan for the right field positionNewsday

Despite Judge's insistence on his readiness, the decision to return him to the outfield has drawn scrutiny. Critics have pointed out that Judge's hesitance to make a critical throw could be indicative of lingering issues with his arm. The Blue Jays, aware of Judge's situation, aimed to test his arm early in the game, which could become a tactical focus for opposing teams as the postseason approaches.

CBS Sports

Boone remarked on the significance of having both Judge and Stanton in the lineup, stating, “Big G putting himself in the mix now is obviously a big deal.” However, he acknowledged the risks involved, particularly regarding Judge's arm and Stanton's defensive limitations. Judge's performance will be closely watched as the Yankees navigate a tight playoff race, with Boone emphasizing the need for both players to remain healthy.

Yankees have a big new plan for the right field position

As the Yankees continue their series against the Blue Jays, they face a critical juncture in their season. With Judge back in the outfield, the team hopes to regain momentum in the AL East race. The Yankees are currently four games behind the Blue Jays, and their ability to secure wins in the upcoming games will be crucial for their playoff aspirations. The Yankees will need to balance Judge's health with their competitive needs as they push towards the postseason.

Yankees’ Aaron Judge back at DH vs. Blue Jays after outfield return