Story perspectives

Rabbi Calls for Broader Zionism Amid NYC Divide

12/11/2025

Center

Rabbi Advocates Zionism

Rabbi Elliot Cosgrove, addressing the American Zionist Movement, discussed Zohran Mamdani, New York City mayor-elect, who received about 33% of the Jewish vote.
He urged American Jews to broaden Zionism and recognize the Israeli-Palestinian conflict's complexities.
Cosgrove criticized policies under Prime Minister Netanyahu, arguing they alienate liberal American Jews.
His remarks reflect a growing Jewish-community divide over Israel and Mamdani's anti-Zionist stance, with safety concerns in New York City.

Left

Mamdani Gains Satmar Support

Zohran Mamdani, New York City mayor-elect, was welcomed at a Satmar Hasidic event celebrating the 'day of rescue'.
The Satmar community endorsed Mamdani after he pledged to protect their yeshivas, following his attendance at gatherings led by both factions.
U.S. President Donald Trump sent a message, emphasizing faith and religious freedom.
The Satmar community opposes drafting Haredi men into the Israeli military, joining a protest outside the Israeli Consulate.

1 of 2

Rabbi Advocates Zionism

Rabbi Elliot Cosgrove, addressing the American Zionist Movement, discussed Zohran Mamdani, New York City mayor-elect, who received about 33% of the Jewish vote.
He urged American Jews to broaden Zionism and recognize the Israeli-Palestinian conflict's complexities.
Cosgrove criticized policies under Prime Minister Netanyahu, arguing they alienate liberal American Jews.
His remarks reflect a growing Jewish-community divide over Israel and Mamdani's anti-Zionist stance, with safety concerns in New York City.

1 / 2