Rising Tensions: Rabbi Elliot Cosgrove's Critique of Zohran Mamdani's Support Among New York Jews

Rabbi Elliot Cosgrove, a prominent figure in the American Jewish community and rabbi of Park Avenue Synagogue, recently addressed the American Zionist Movement's Biennial National Assembly in New York City. His remarks focused on the surprising support that New York City mayor-elect Zohran Mamdani received from Jewish voters, noting that approximately 33% of Jewish voters backed Mamdani, who is known for his anti-Zionist stance. Cosgrove's comments come amid a broader discussion about the evolving relationship between American Jews and Israel, particularly among younger generations.

The Jerusalem ReportTimes of Israel

Cosgrove articulated that the support for Mamdani should not be shocking, as many liberal Zionists feel disillusioned by the current Israeli government. He stated, “For a liberal Zionist disillusioned by the Israeli government, Mamdani’s anti-Zionism is a difference of degree, not of kind.” He emphasized the need for the Jewish community to engage in self-reflection regarding its internal divisions and the perception of Israel among younger Jews, who increasingly view the Israeli state as a "Goliath" in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

Times of IsraelIn AZM address, Cosgrove links communal “orthodoxy” on Israel to rising anti-Zionism among young Jews

Cosgrove's speech elicited mixed reactions from the audience, which included a diverse array of political and religious affiliations. Some attendees applauded his call for introspection, while others expressed dissatisfaction, highlighting the contentious atmosphere surrounding discussions of Israel within the Jewish community. He urged the community to avoid labeling dissenters as "self-hating Jews," advocating instead for a more inclusive dialogue that recognizes the complexities of Jewish identity and political beliefs.

In AZM address, Cosgrove links communal “orthodoxy” on Israel to rising anti-Zionism among young Jews

Israeli President Isaac Herzog, who also spoke at the assembly, echoed concerns about Mamdani's election, describing him as having "utter contempt" for Israel. Herzog's remarks included a warning about the potential dangers posed to the Jewish community under Mamdani's leadership, particularly in light of rising antisemitism. He emphasized the need for unity within the Jewish community and the importance of understanding diverse perspectives.

Times of IsraelIn AZM address, Cosgrove links communal “orthodoxy” on Israel to rising anti-Zionism among young Jews

Mamdani's political positions, including his refusal to condemn anti-Israel slogans and his controversial statements regarding Israel's legitimacy, have drawn criticism from various Jewish leaders. Despite this, Mamdani has garnered support from leftist Jewish allies and has pledged to protect Jewish communities in New York City. However, a recent poll indicated that a majority of "connected" American Jews believe Mamdani's leadership could make them less safe.

Times of Israel

As Mamdani prepares to take office in January 2026, the Jewish community in New York City faces a pivotal moment. The election of an anti-Zionist mayor represents a significant shift, prompting urgent discussions about identity, belonging, and the future of Jewish political engagement in America. Rabbi Cosgrove's call for a "self-audit" within the community reflects a growing recognition of the need for dialogue and understanding in an increasingly polarized environment.

Times of Israel