The Candy Heir's Campaign Against Chocolate Skimpflation

Brad Reese, the grandson of H.B. Reese, founder of Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, has launched a campaign against The Hershey Company, accusing it of "skimpflation." This term describes the practice of reducing product quality instead of raising prices in response to inflationary pressures. Reese's concerns arose after he discovered that Reese's Mini Hearts were made with "chocolate candy" and "peanut butter crème" rather than the traditional milk chocolate and peanut butter combination. Disappointed, Reese discarded the product and publicly criticized Hershey's for altering the brand's identity.

NPR

The concept of skimpflation has gained traction as companies face rising costs due to supply chain disruptions, labor challenges, and tariffs. Cocoa, a key ingredient in chocolate, has seen price volatility, exacerbated by climate change affecting production in West Africa. In late 2024, cocoa prices reached record highs, prompting companies like Hershey's to reconsider their ingredient formulations. Although recent tariff exemptions and improved cocoa production have alleviated some cost pressures, the legacy of skimpflation remains.

NPR

Brad Reese is a prominent figure in this narrative, leveraging his family legacy to advocate for product integrity. His campaign includes an open letter to Hershey's executives and a revamped website emphasizing his commitment to protecting the Reese's brand. In contrast, The Hershey Company maintains that its iconic Reese's Peanut Butter Cups are still made with traditional ingredients, while acknowledging that some newer products may not meet the federal definition of "milk chocolate."

NPR

In response to Reese's allegations, Hershey's stated that their classic Reese's Peanut Butter Cups continue to be made with fresh peanuts and milk chocolate. However, they also noted that as the product line has expanded, some recipes have been adjusted to create new shapes and sizes. This has led to the introduction of products that do not conform to the traditional definitions of chocolate and peanut butter, which Reese argues undermines the brand's integrity.

NPR

Critics, including Lindsay Owens, Executive Director of the Groundwork Collaborative, argue that skimpflation poses health risks due to the increased use of processed ingredients. Owens highlights that skimpflation can account for significant inflation in various product categories and calls for greater transparency in labeling practices. She suggests that consumers often lack complete information about the products they purchase, which can lead to misunderstandings regarding ingredient quality.

NPR

As the debate over skimpflation continues, Owens advocates for federal authorities to reassess labeling regulations to ensure consumers have clear information about product ingredients. The ongoing discourse surrounding Reese's campaign may prompt corporations to reconsider their ingredient choices and transparency practices, potentially influencing the broader market landscape.

NPR

• “Reese (who invented Reese's), built Reese's on a simple, enduring architecture: milk chocolate + peanut butter.” — Brad Reese, Candy Heir

NPR

• “shrinkflation accounted for as much as 10% of total inflation” — Lindsay Owens, Executive Director, Groundwork Collaborative

NPR

• “As innovations and forms change over time, those updates are always reflected in on-pack ingredient information, which is the most accurate and up-to-date source for consumers.” — The Hershey Company, Official Statement

NPR

This evolving situation highlights the intersection of consumer advocacy, corporate practices, and regulatory oversight in the candy industry.

NPR