Story perspectives

Pennsylvania Republicans Prefer Fetterman Over McCormick, Poll Finds

8/27/2026

Left

Fetterman Wins GOP

An August 2026 poll showed Pennsylvania Republican voters favor Democrat Senator John Fetterman over Republican Senator Dave McCormick.
Democratic voters expressed a strong desire for elected officials to oppose President Donald Trump, and Fetterman's waning Democratic support reflects that sentiment.
Two-thirds of likely Democratic voters say Fetterman supports President Donald Trump too frequently.
Only 66 % of Republican voters favor McCormick, while 79 % favor Fetterman.

Right

Fetterman Wins GOP

An August 2026 statewide poll found Pennsylvania Republican voters prefer Democrat Senator John Fetterman to Republican Senator Dave McCormick.
Republican Senate leaders said they would publicly welcome Fetterman if he chose to join the GOP.
Fetterman’s Republican favorability rose significantly from 25 % in 2024 to 73 % in 2026.
Consultant Matt Beynon said voters value Fetterman’s willingness to confront his party’s radical wing on antisemitism.

Center

Fetterman Wins GOP

A poll released in August 2026 found Pennsylvania Republican voters favor Democrat Senator John Fetterman over Republican Senator Dave McCormick.
Polymarket prediction contracts assigned a 7 % probability that Fetterman will switch parties before the 2026 midterm elections.
Fetterman said he has no intention to leave the Democratic Party and will continue focusing on Pennsylvania.
Seventy-three percent of self-identified Republicans view Fetterman favorably, versus 63 % for McCormick.

Blindspot

The poll showed Democratic voters want officials to oppose President Donald Trump, with 47% saying Fetterman's stance is about right, 38% that he supports Trump too much, and two-thirds saying he supports Trump too frequently.
Within this story's sources, this angle appears mainly in Left-leaning coverage and receives less attention in Center- and Right-leaning coverage.

History

Historical Context

In September 1964, Senator Strom Thurmond of South Carolina left the Democratic Party to support Barry Goldwater, opposing the party’s civil-rights agenda. His switch helped the GOP capture South Carolina with 59% of the vote, and he won re-election in 1966 with 62.2% of the statewide vote. A 2026 Pennsylvania poll showing Democrat John Fetterman 73% favorable among Republicans mirrors Thurmond’s cross-party appeal.

1 of 5

Fetterman Wins GOP

An August 2026 poll showed Pennsylvania Republican voters favor Democrat Senator John Fetterman over Republican Senator Dave McCormick.
Democratic voters expressed a strong desire for elected officials to oppose President Donald Trump, and Fetterman's waning Democratic support reflects that sentiment.
Two-thirds of likely Democratic voters say Fetterman supports President Donald Trump too frequently.
Only 66 % of Republican voters favor McCormick, while 79 % favor Fetterman.

1 / 5