Major FedEx Truck Heist Targets PSA-Graded Trading Cards

Police said thieves broke into a FedEx truck parked near Professional Sports Authenticator’s (PSA) Santa Ana facility on October 13. Two full pallets of graded cards and a third partially “disrupted” pallet were taken, with an initial valuation of $963,000. The exact loss could rise as the remaining boxes from the third pallet await scanning.

Heavy

• October 13 – Santa Ana Police receive a report of the break-in at the 1600 block of E. St. Andrew Place.

NBC Los Angeles

• October 17 – Collector “SKY-B” posts on X that his 104-card order, valued at over $100,000, was stolen.

IGN Entertainment

• October 19 – PSA issues a public statement outlining its response and preliminary valuation.

PSA FedEx Truck Theft May Top $1 Million in Stolen Cards

• Ongoing – Police and FedEx continue the investigation; no arrests have been announced.

FedEx Truck Theft Takes $963,000 in Cards as Cargo Losses Climb

• Approximately 250 packages (?200 from two full pallets, ?50 from the third) were removed.

Heavy

• SKY-B’s shipment was insured for $156,000 and incurred $8,000 in grading fees.

IGN Entertainment

• Boston Card Hunter’s crowd-sourced list names 383 serialized cards, including a 1995 Upper Deck 23K Gold Michael Jordan (50,000-print run) and a 2024 One Piece Simplified Chinese 1st Anniversary Set Nami.

PSA Graded Cards Stolen From FedEx Truck, Collector Says $100,000 Order Lost

• Verisk CargoNet reports cargo-theft losses of $304.6 million in Q2 2026, more than double the prior year’s figure.

FedEx Truck Theft Takes $963,000 in Cards as Cargo Losses Climb

• PSA has deactivated certificates for the stolen items, notified marketplace partners, and will compensate customers based on fair market value up to each card’s Maximum Insured Value (MIV).

Heavy

• Santa Ana Police Department spokesperson Natalie Garcia: The theft’s value could rise; the case remains open with no arrests or recoveries reported.

NBC Los Angeles

Industry commentator Darren Rovell warned that the incident exposes systemic vulnerabilities, stating, “The simple name PSA or Collectors in the address box is the threat,” and urging immediate changes to shipping and insurance practices.

Heavy

• “The exact value of what was stolen could not be determined until the remaining boxes were scanned.” — Police

FedEx truck heist makes PSA collectors victims of nearly $1 million card theft

• “There must be a change and it must be today,” — Darren Rovell

Heavy

• PSA’s preliminary estimate of $963,000 for two pallets contrasts with community speculation that total declared value may approach $1 million.

Heavy

• Boston Card Hunter cited a $500,000 declared-value figure for other customers, but that number has not been independently verified.

IGN Entertainment

• The precise count of stolen cards and the final monetary total remain undetermined pending the scan of the third pallet and further police accounting.

NBC Los Angeles

• The theft underscores the escalating financial stakes in the trading-card market.

NBC News

• Deactivating PSA certification numbers creates a traceable safeguard, yet thieves could remove cards from slabs, complicating recovery.

PSA Card Theft: $100K+ Reported Stolen From FedEx Truck

• Collectors may reassess reliance on standard carrier services for high-value returns, potentially shifting toward armored transport or direct hand-delivery.

PSA Deactivates Stolen Slabs After FedEx Truck Theft Hits Collectors for More Than $100,000

• PSA will contact affected customers individually and finalize compensation based on fair market value.

PSA FedEx Truck Theft May Top $1 Million in Stolen Cards

• Santa Ana Police continue to solicit tips at 714-245-8665.

NBC Los Angeles

• The broader freight-industry data suggests that high-value shipments will face heightened scrutiny and may prompt policy revisions for carrier security and insurance.

FedEx Truck Theft Takes $963,000 in Cards as Cargo Losses Climb